Thursday, August 24, 2006

Who do you save????

I stole this off La Chou's website and thought it was pretty fun. In a creative writing class and in a group, she had to pretend she was a rescuer sent to a flooding cave. These seven people are trapped. What order do you save them in with the thought that the last person on your list probably won't make it. I'll post what I thought and what she put in the comments so as not to sway your decisions. If you want to play along, write down your answers first so there are no influences. Interested to see what people say...

Seven people are trapped in a cave. Water is slowly rising and will eventually fill the cave. Quite possibly only six people will be rescued and one will have to die. Rank the people in the order you think they should be brought out of the cave.

Helen-White, American, female, age 34. She is married with four very young children. She left college to be married, and is suspected of having a sexual affair with Owen.

Tozo-Japanese, female, age 19. She is very attractive, and has grown up in a wealthy family. She was recently in a feature film about Japan.

John-Black, American, male, age 37. He is married with five children. He is a full time social worker who enjoys camping with his family.

Owen-White, American, male, age 47. Unmarried P.E. teacher. Former Army Officer. Has a leg injury that is not serious. Also has a bit of a drinking problem.

Paul-White, English, male, age 47. Divorced with no children. He's a medical research student at University Hospital. Is an expert in treating rabies. Twice convicted of indecent exposure.

Edward-White, American, male, age 59. Married with two grown children and seven grandchildren. City coucil member. He enjoys caving and plans to write a book on that subject when he retires.

Jean-Black, Jamaican, female, age 72. Unmarried with no relatives. She has a Ph.D in biological sciences and is working with a government grant to explore biological organisms that grow in caves. She is working on a possible AIDS vaccine. She also studies the behavior of people in confined spaces.

8 comments:

MrManuel said...

What she said...

1.Jean-It would be best to get the oldest/frailest person out first. She also has studied the behavior of people in caves and could possibly help the rescuers determine who needs to be rescued next.

2.Helen-Has small children and quite possibly is out of shape (I'm assuming a lot). Also might have emotional problems.

3.John-Has a family. Don't know how fit he is.

4.Paul-Possible emotional problems. Possibly out of shape.

5.Owen-Physically fit. Also has military experience.

6.Tozo-Quite possibly small (better fitting through small spaces even underwater.

7.Edward-Caving experience and training. More fit than others.

MrManuel said...

What I said...

I went:
Jean - Old
Helen - mother of 4
Tozo - I guess because I wan tot get the women out first
John - father of 4
Edward - older male, but didn't go sooner because he does have some experiences with caves
Owen - Slightly injured, but in shape
Paul - People with no emotion would have taken him sooner, but my thoughts of what he had done in the past got the best of me and he goes last...

Anonymous said...

Save by age, oldest first. The pervert can be last. That's what he gets.

Miss Sassy Pants said...

John
Jean
Paul
Edward
Helen
Owen
Tozo

I saved them by the order they had something to contribute to society...

Anonymous said...

Jean
John
Edward
Helen
Tozo
Owen
Paul
I based it on if the person sounded like a good person and if they had family.

Anonymous said...

this is a tough one because my natural instinct is to say women first and then go oldest to youngest. But, as we know from watching Survivor some of the old could be strong and the young can be weak and stupid. Edward and Jean both have contributions inside and outside of the cave but really how fit are they - I also want to save John because he has a family. You guys all had valid reasons. I think I might need a little more information.

MrManuel said...

Nani - Yeah, perv last!

Jess - Wouldn't Jean have more to contribute to society?

Cass - Good rationale!

Mom - When the cave is filling, I don't think you have time for more info

La Chou - That is why I posted this. It is interesting to see the different ways people prioritize

Miss Sassy Pants said...

Good point... Ultimately though, Jean, John, they both get saved, who cares...